Skip to content
Staging environment — review version. Do not share.

Research and InnovationResearch Radar

The mental health impacts of childhood adversity may be delayed for some young people

Children who do not develop mental health problems early in life despite exposure to multiple adversities may...

By João L. de Quevedo, MD, PhD

Published on · Last reviewed on · 2 min read

Children who do not develop mental health problems early in life despite exposure to multiple adversities may face such challenges in early adulthood, suggests a report published in The American Journal of Psychiatry.

“Although resilient individuals may emerge from childhood relatively unscathed, the stress of maintaining psychological health despite adversity may catch up with them later in development,” wrote William E. Copeland, Ph.D., of the University of Vermont, and colleagues.

Copeland and colleagues examined data from The Great Smoky Mountains Study, a longitudinal study that followed the outcomes of three cohorts of children (aged 9, 11, and 13 years) recruited from 11 counties in western North Carolina. Annual assessments were conducted with the children and caregivers every year until the children reached age 16; the young people were assessed on their own at ages 19, 21, 25, and 30. Through age 16, the young people answered questions about childhood adversities, which the researchers categorized into the following five domains:

  • low socioeconomic status
  • unstable family structure
  • family dysfunction
  • maltreatment
  • peer victimization

The researchers estimated cumulative childhood exposure to adversity by counting the number of adversity categories experienced.

Copeland and colleagues analyzed reports from 1,266 participants who answered questions about psychiatric disorders and functioning at age 25 and/or 30. Of this group, 941 (74%) had experienced psychiatric disorders or subthreshold psychiatric symptoms by age 16. Of the 325 (26%) who did not meet criteria for a psychiatric diagnosis or subthreshold disorder by age 16, 63 had been exposed to multiple childhood adversities. (The authors characterized these young people as “resilient.”)

The investigators found that, compared with children with limited exposure to adversity and no childhood disorders (the low-risk/no-disorder group), resilient children had nearly 3 times the risk of developing anxiety and 4.5 times the risk of developing depression in adulthood. In addition, the resilient group had poorer physical and financial health compared with individuals in the low-risk/no-disorder group. However, the resilient group showed better functioning than the group of participants with childhood psychiatric problems in the domains of health and social functioning.

“Thus, the well-being of adults characterized as resilient children was better than that of adults with childhood psychiatric problems, but sometimes worse than that of adults exposed to less childhood adversity,” the authors wrote. “[T]he development of some level of mental health problems is the normative response to significant adversity. Individual resilience followed by persistent mental health is rare and may not be a reasonable goal. Public health efforts should prioritize risk reduction and treatment of individuals who are ill.”

To read more on this topic, see the Psychiatric News article “Intervention and Resilience May Counter the Impact of Poverty on Brain Development.”

Related content

Mood Disorders

Understanding the complexity of catatonia

Catatonia, a perplexing neuropsychiatric condition, often remains poorly understood despite its profound impact on...

· Explainer